"Anyone who follows politics and courts can surely identify a list of such issues. Among the most salient are those dealing with the separation of church and state, gun rights, LGBTQ rights, abortion, affirmative action, immigration, the death penalty, business regulation, and in recent years, just about anything involving [Donald] Trump.]
Research & Commentary on the Supreme Court, the New York Court of Appeals, More
Tuesday, December 31, 2024
Splinters in the 6-3 Supreme Court (Part 1: Amy Coney Barrett)
"Anyone who follows politics and courts can surely identify a list of such issues. Among the most salient are those dealing with the separation of church and state, gun rights, LGBTQ rights, abortion, affirmative action, immigration, the death penalty, business regulation, and in recent years, just about anything involving [Donald] Trump.]
Thursday, October 22, 2020
Supreme Shift: Ginsburg to Barrett (Part 1)
The magnitude of the shift was certainly not matched by a magnitude of serious deliberation.
![]() |
| Olivier Douliery/AFP |
Democrats decried the hypocrisy of the Republicans who had refused to hold a hearing during an election year when President Obama nominated Judge Merrick Garland. The Democrats also sounded alarms about the likely ramifications of an ideologically conservative Barrett replacing liberal Ginsburg. Republicans, not surprisingly, insisted that there was no such hypocrisy. They also lauded Barrett's avowed judicial restraint in decision-making, while insisting that her asserted embrace of originalism and textualism had nothing to do with any perceived ideological bent. After four days, the pre-ordained result seemed nothing but pre-ordained.
Whatever the partisan wrangling and dissembling may otherwise suggest--about the Barrett nomination and Barrett herself--there are some simple realities. Ruth Bader Ginsburg was selected by Democratic President Bill Clinton. She was heralded for her successful litigation on behalf of equal rights for women, and her record on the Court over 27 years was unmistakably liberal across the wide swath of issues from abortion rights to affirmative action to gender equality to immigration to LGBTQ rights to racial justice to the rights of the accused, etc.
By contrast, Amy Coney Barrett was selected by Republican Donald Trump. Her nomination was urged by supporters because of her ideological leanings that are distinctly contrary to those of Ginsburg, and for her judicial record which, albeit brief, reflects a polar opposite jurisprudence. In short, by all accounts, she is very ideologically conservative.
So let's take a look at the change that's in store--a change for the Court with a Justice Barrett who presumably would behave consistently with her record as Judge Barrett.
Here's what the ideological line-up of the Justices looked like in the immediately past term, with Ginsburg still on the Court:
(click to enlarge)
Based upon the politically conservative groups that urged the nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett, the promises President Trump has made about the kind of judges and Justices he would nominate, the support Barrett has been receiving from politically conservative Republican Senators, her academic writings and lectures, her record as a federal appellate judge--based on all of that evidence, there is every reason to believe that a Justice Barrett would be positioned firmly within the politically conservative wing of the Court. That is, there is every reason to believe that she would be voting with the politically conservative Justices on the politically conservative side of the liberal versus conservative, "hot button" issues.
Based on the previously listed evidence, it is safe to assume that her ideological bent is no less conservative than that of Trump's first two nominees, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh. Indeed, she might well be even more ideologically aligned with most conservative among the conservative Justices--i.e., Thomas and Alito.
At the least, her appointment to the Court would alter the previous 5 to 4 politically conservative majority on the Court--or the arguable 4 to 4 ideological balance with Chief Justice Roberts as the "'swing" vote. That would change to a 6 to 3 conservative majority--or arguably a 5-4 conservative majority with Roberts splitting his votes between the Court's two ideological wings. Putting the change more starkly, Judge Barrett's addition to the Court, filling the Ginsburg vacancy, would mean twice as many politically conservative Justices on the Court as liberals. Even more stark? The politically conservative Justices would still constitute a majority without Roberts' vote. The liberals on the Court would need two of the politically conservative Justices to vote their way to ever reach a majority.
To be sure, it is within the realm of possibility that Judge Barrett might experience an ideological and jurisprudential conversion over her tenure on the Court. It has certainly happened to others. Republican appointees have sometimes transitioned to staunch jurisprudential liberals. Nixon appointee Harry Blackmun, Ford appointee John Paul Stevens, and Bush (41) appointee David Souter come readily to mind. And Reagan appointees Sandra Day O'Connor and Anthony Kennedy, even if never quite liberals, both became "swing votes" during their tenures, joining their liberal colleagues on some major social issues.
Absent such a dramatic ideological transformation, however, Judge Barrett's addition to the Court will result in a dramatic ideological transformation of the Court itself. Amy Coney Barrett replacing Ruth Bader Ginsburg? That is dramatic.
One more note before concluding. Imagine for a moment that remote chance that the Barrett nomination were to fail. What would the Court look like if a President Biden, rather than President Trump, were to fill the Ginsburg vacancy? Take a look:
(click to enlarge)
Tuesday, June 30, 2020
It's Roberts' (somewhat less right-wing) Court (Part 3)
![]() |
| Source:Reuters/Leah Mills |
Let's finish this series by recalling a few other decisions reflecting the same pattern. Perhaps these cases, like those we've previously discussed, evince a Chief Justice concerned primarily about the legitimacy of his Court, i.e., rebuffing criticisms that it is just another institution polarized along partisan lines. Perhaps it's Roberts holding his Court together by giving the benefit of the doubt to the Court's liberals--at least every once in a while in close cases where he could honestly support either side. Perhaps it's the Chief Justice upholding the integrity of the Court's authority by supporting precedents against which he had originally dissented (as he just now did again in the Louisiana abortion case). Or perhaps it's actually the Chief Justice changing his mind after some time for reconsideration.
Again, whatever the reason--and likely there are different reasons in different cases--the emerging pattern is clear. Roberts has given political liberals, both on and off the Court, some significant victories

(Of course this has not escaped the President's notice--and ire.)
Okay, enough with preliminaries. Let's get to the last few cases we'll look at in this series that illustrate the pattern that may well be the most salient characteristic of this otherwise quite politically conservative Court.
Church and State. Late last month, the Chief Justice joined his liberal colleagues in refusing to lift the COVID-crisis restrictions on church attendance that had been imposed by California's governor. Roberts' 4 conservative colleagues all dissented. Justice Kavanaugh, in an opinion joined by Justices Thomas and Gorsuch, argued that the numerical limitations on gatherings and the requirement for social distancing unconstitutionally discriminated against religious exercise. This was so, according to Kavanaugh, because other similarly situated activities did not face such restrictions. [Alito's dissenting vote was simply noted.]
Although the Court's decision was merely an order, Roberts' authored an opinion explaining why the majority got it right. The standard for granting emergency relief is that the constitutional merits are already "indisputably clear." Roberts deemed it "quite improbable" that the religious objectors could show that. Two basic reasons. First, despite the dissenters' claim, "only dissimilar activities...in which people neither congregate in large groups nor remain in close proximity for extended periods" are treated more leniently than churches. Second, the need for restrictions "during the pandemic is a dynamic and fact-intensive matter subject to reasonable disagreement," which the Constitution "principally entrusts" to the "especially broad" latitude of the states' political officials. And such matters of public health and safety should usually "not be subject to second-guessing" by the federal judiciary.
In short, the Chief Justice disagreed with his conservative colleagues that the religious objectors had demonstrated that they were being treated disparately or too harshly. South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom, 2020.
Three years earlier, in another church-state case, Roberts held the middle ground to which some of his conservative colleagues and some of his liberal colleagues objected--naturally for different reasons. Writing the opinion for the Court, the Chief Justice explained that the ineligibility of religious organizations from a state program that subsidized the safety improvement of school playgrounds violated free exercise--i.e., the disqualification discriminated on the basis of religion, despite the purely secular purpose of the program's assistance.
Although Justices Kennedy and Alito joined Roberts' opinion in full, Thomas and Gorsuch objected that the ruling was too limited--i.e., it should not have been limited to playground safety, nor to secular versus religious uses.
While Justice Kagan fully joined Roberts' opinion, Breyer wrote a separate concurence to emphasize that the program in question, as well as the Court's ruling, was limited to a public service--here "the health and safety of children." The remaining liberals, Justice Sotomayor joined by Ginsburg, dissented on the ground that directly funding a religious organization violated the constitution's non-establishment mandate.
Here, as we have seen elsewhere, the Chief Justice struck a balance. He crafted a ruling that was narrow enough to secure a majority, despite differences or even dissents from some of his more ideologically-driven colleagues--conservative or liberal. Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. Comer, (2017).
Right to Choose/Abortion Rights. Four years ago, in Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt, the Court ruled that a Texas law, that limited which physicians and facilities could provide abortion servoces, imposed an unconstitutional "undue burden" on a woman's right to choose. Chief Justice Roberts dissented, along with his conservative colleagues, Justices Thomas and Alito. [Justice Scalia had recently passed away and his vacancy had not yet been filled.]
Since that decision, Justice Gorsuch was appointed to fill Scalia's seat, and Justice Kavanaugh was appointed to replace Justice Kennedy who had retired in the interim. With Kennedy now missing from the 5 Justices who comprised the majority in Whole Woman’s Health, the Court was confronted this term with another case term involving similar abortion retrictions. This time the state was Louisiana, but the restrictions, the prospective consequences, and the outcome were similar. Only physicians with privileges at a nearby hospital could perform abortions. The restrictions would drastically reduce the availability of abortion services. The restrictions were ostensibly to protect the health of women. The restrictions, according to expert analysis, actually had minimal health-related benefits. And the Court again found such restrictions to be an unconstitutional burden on a women's right to choose.
The big difference? This time the Chief Justice sided with the liberals to give them the bare 5-4 majority. In a separate concurrence, Roberts insisted that he still believed that Whole Woman’s Health was wrongly decided. But, in a 16 page opinion in which he reviewed the reasons for stare decisis and the Court's abortion rights precedents to date, the Chief Justice set forth a jurisprudence that has become a distinctive part of his opinion and voting patterns: "The legal doctrine of stare decisis requires us, absent special circumstances, to treat like cases alike." [My emphasis.] Then, he concluded by applying that formula to his vote in this case: "The result in this case is controlled by our decision four years ago invalidating a nearly identical Texas law"--despite his disagreement then. June Medical Services L. L. C. v. Russo, 2020.
[Notably, Roberts signaled his thinking about this case when, in February 2019, he joined the liberals to form the same 5-4 majority to grant an order stopping the Louisiana law from taking effect while litigation was pending.]
One last one. This is one of my very favorites. I've written about it previously on New York Court Watcher.
Technological Searches. In the last few decades, the Court has seriously diluted constitutional search and seizure protections. It has done so, for example,
- by adding exceptions to the warrant requirement (e.g., warrantless searches and seizures incident to minor traffic infractions);
- by adding exceptions to the rule excluding unconstitutionally obtained evidence (e.g., the "good faith" exception);
- by diluting what is required for probable cause (i.e., the "totality of the circumstances" test);
- by diluting the 1967 landmark Katz decision which protected legitimate expectations of privacy (e.g., denying legitimacy to a host of privacy expectations);
- by (mis)using that landmark's formula in order to rule that searches are not "searches" for constitutional purposes (e.g., police searches from a hovering helicopter);
- by employing doctrines such as "third party" (i.e., if anyone else has access to information about you, then government needs no warrant or probable cause to access it);
- and "public access" (i.e., if members of the public can see you in a public place, then government can surveil you without a warrant or probable cause);
- and "tresspass" (i.e., equating search and seizure rights to property rights whereby a physical tresspass is necessary to constitute a violation);
- by limiting search and seizure protections to those specific items enumerated in the 4th Amendment.
Well, two years ago, Chief Justice Roberts joined the liberals and, in the 5-4 majority opinion he assigned to himself, he avoided or simply dispensed with some of those foregoing dilutions--to the considerable consternation of his more law and order minded colleagues. Roberts wrote that a warrant supported by probable cause is required for law enforcement to access cellphone location data about a suspect from a cellphone company. No, the fact that some entity, the company itself, already had access to the information (i.e., the third party doctrine) didn't allow the government to have warrantless access. No, the fact that the data did not belong to the individual, but to the company (i.e., the property rights/tresspass doctrine), didn't mean that the individual was without some entitlement to privacy from the government. No, the fact that the individual's movements and location in public might be observed by members of the public (i.e., public access doctrine), didn't mean that he had no legitimate expectation of privacy from government surveilance. Etc.
Yes, acknowledged Roberts, the Court's opinion six years earlier in U.S. v. Jones, authored by Justice Scalia, did assert that the warrantless monitoring of a suspect's movements and location was unconstitutional because the police had "tresspassed" on his property--i.e., by attaching a GPS device to his vehicle without his consent. But, the Chief Justice pointed out that a majority of the Justices in Jones had actually reaffairmed the Katz "legitimate expectation of privacy" doctrine. There was Justice Alito and the 3 liberals who joined his concurring opinion, stridently rejecting Scalia's tresspass analysis in favor of Katz; and Justice Sotomayor who authored a separate concurrence, joining Scalia but also reaffirming Katz.
As Roberts explained in declining to apply some of the previously adopted doctrines, "few could have imagined a society in which a phone goes wherever its owner goes, conveying to the wireless carrier not just dialed digits, but a detailed and comprehensive record of the person’s movements." He went further: "Apart from disconnecting the phone from the network, there is no way to avoid leaving behind a trail of location data. As a result, in no meaningful sense does the user voluntarily 'assume[] the risk' of turning over a comprehensive dossier of his physical movements."
The concerns expressed by the Chief Justice in his majority opinion sounded much more like those of the liberal Justices who had previously dissented while the Court was diluting search and seizure protections. And Roberts' conservative collegues in this case understood that and objected to his aligning with the liberals in refusing to apply those law and order doctrines. Carpenter v. U.S., 2018.
[For more on the Carpenter decision, see The Supreme's Cell Location Data Decision: Right, Revealing, and a Real Milestone, June 26, 2018.]
There are other cases--an increasing number of them at that--where Chief Justice Roberts has indeed established a distinct pattern of parting with his usual ideological allies on the Court and siding with the liberals to form a majority on some major, highly-charged issues. That point, I believe, has been well made, and continuing further is not only uneccessary but perhaps fatiguing. So we shall end here.
Of course, decisions handed down by the Court in the next few days, as the current term comes to a close, may well make all of the foregoing seem like wishful thinking based on a a few isolated exceptions. But the pattern is there, it is clear, and there no particular reason to think that it won't continue.
Thursday, June 25, 2020
It's Roberts' (somewhat less right-wing) Court (Part 2)
![]() |
| Source: AP/Dave Tulis/Larry Downing |
We witnessed exactly that last week in the DACA case (Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the University of California, 2020) which was discussed in the previous post. Let's now turn to last week's other momentous decision, as well as an earlier related one that is, perhaps, even more revealing about the role and direction of Roberts as the primus inter pares.
LGBTQ Rights. In a long-awaited decision--it took over 8 months from oral arguments on October 8, 2019--the Court ruled last week that the prohibition against "sex" discrimination in the Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects gay and transgender employees. The Chief Justice joined his 4 liberal colleagues, as well as one of the Trump-appointed conservative Justices, Neil Gorsuch, to whom he assigned the writing of the majority opinion.
Over the dissents of the 3 remaining Republican appointees [Thomas, Alito, and Kavanaugh], the Roberts-assigned/Gorsuch-penned majority opinion agreed with the fired employees that discrimination on the basis of "sex" necessarily covered discrimination against gays and transgenders. The crux of the argument [distilled from what I found to be a mostly insufferable 33 pages] was that the term "sex," as a matter of sheer linguistics and logic, does apply to gays and transgenders, even if that application was not within the underlying legislative intent of the law.
The 3 remaining conservatives wrote 134 combined pages of dissent. Justice Samuel Alito's seething 107-page opinion, joined by Justice Clarence Thomas, as well as the separate dissent of Justice Brett Kavanaugh, evinced frustration triggered not only by the Court's decision, but no doubt also by the loss of another Roberts vote to the liberals--this time, together with Gorsuch's vote as well. Bostock v. Clayton County, 2020.
[I feel compelled to add that, regardless of my unqualified agreement with the Court's result, I find much of the majority opinion unnecessary, unpersuasive, and perilous. The same decision could have been reached by simply sticking to the inexorable logic of what sex discrimination necessarily includes. (E.g., if a woman prefers men, that's ok. But if a man does, that's not? The only difference is the different sex of the person who prefers men.)
Beyond that, a far better majority opinion, in my view, would have embraced the overarching principle in prohibiting sex discrimination. Sex and sex-related characteristics are utterly irrelevant for most purposes. For like reason, most disparate treatment on those bases is born of bigotry or some other form of ignorance, rather than some justified reason--which is precisely what discrimination means.
On the other hand, Gorsuch’s "it’s clear from the original understanding of the plain terms of the statute" argument (I’m paraphrasing) can be expected to be used in the future to support reactionary results. The 6 votes his opinion received will surely be used as a strong endorsement of his insistent originalism—i.e., the “ordinary public meaning” of the terms of the law “at the time of the enactment" (his language)—about which he waxed and waned ad nauseam. This will be thrown back at the liberals--all of whom joined his opinion without a whisper of discomfort--when he and the other conservatives (including those in dissent in this case) use it in future cases to undercut past progress and block attempts to move the law forward.
I wish at least one of the liberal Justices had authored a separate concurrence making clear that they weren’t endorsing Gorsuch’s originalist interpretive approach. The need to do so should have been especially clear in light of Alito's dissenting opinion. Regarding what "sex discrimination" was understood to mean "at the time of enactment," Alito's dissent had the much stronger argument. Just consider this: would the law's prohibition of "sex discrimination" have been passed--"at the time of enactment" in 1964--if legislators were told that those terms protected gays and transgenders as well as women? Now ask the same question about progressive interpretations of countless other statutory and constitutional provisions. The liberals should at least have expressed their reservations about the originalism touted by Gorsuch.
Others have raised similar concerns. See e.g., Neil Gorsuch Lays Landmines Throughout LGBTQ Discrimination Opinion. https://abovethelaw.com/2020/06/neil-gorsuch-lays-landmines-throughout-lgbtq-discrimination-opinion/]
In a per curiam opinion, with the Chief Justice in the 6-3 majority, the Court invalidated an Arkansas rule that treated same-sex and opposite-sex spouses differently on their children's birth certificates. While the male spouses of biological mothers were entitled to be identified, female spouses were not. Repeatedly quoting from the Obergefell majority opinion--against which the Chief Justice had originally dissented--Roberts, together with his 4 liberal colleagues and Justice Kennedy, summarily granted review, reversed the state's supreme court, and struck the Arkansas practice on the ground that "the Constitution entitles same-sex couples to civil marriage 'on the same terms and conditions as opposite-sex couples.'”
Justice Gorsuch, this time writing a dissent, which was joined by Thomas and Alito, argued that, although the Obergefell decision held that "a State must recognize same-sex marriages," it said "nothing" about "a birth registration regime based on biology." In response, the Roberts-joined per curiam majority noted that opposite-sex spouses identified on Arkansas birth certificates need not be biological parents. Applying another line excerpted from Obergefell, the Chief Justice and his more liberal colleagues concluded that Arkansas has "denied married same-sex couples access to the 'constellation of benefits that the Stat[e] ha[s] linked to marriage.'” Pavan v. Smith, 2017.
Roberts had thus apparently decided that his role as Chief Justice included adhering to the Court's recent progressive landmark and opposing attempts to undermine it--regardless of his original position on the matter.
Death Penalty/Intellectual Disability. A similar pattern is evident in positions taken by Roberts in some recent death penalty cases. He had dissented in Moore v. Texas when that case came before the Court in 2017. The Court's majority ruled that the state court's judgment that the death row inmate was mentally competent to be executed "had no grounding in prevailing medical practice." Accordingly, the case was remanded for a determination "informed by the medical community’s diagnostic framework." Roberts dissented on the ground that the "independent basis for [the state court's] judgment" was adequate.
When the case returned to the Supreme Court two years later, the majority once again disapproved the state court's determination that the inmate was competent. This time, however, the Chief Justice broke with the conservative dissenters [Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch] and joined the majority [which notably included Justice Kavanaugh]. Despite Roberts' own previous dissent, he acknowledged that the Texas determination "did not pass muster under this Court’s analysis last time" and, because "[i]t still doesn’t," he joined the majority's opinion to again reverse the state court's judgment. Moore v. Texas, 2019.
The Chief Justice joined his liberal colleagues in several other related death penalty cases in 2019. A few weeks prior to the Court's decision in Moore, Roberts signaled his break with his conservative colleagues in White v. Kentucky. In that early 2019 decision, he joined the majority's order [over the dissent of Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch] to grant review and simultaneously, without argument, reverse a judgment of the state's supreme court--on the basis of the Court's earlier 2017 Moore decision.
Similarly, in Madison v. Alabama, also decided in early 2019, Roberts again broke with his conservative colleagues [Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch]. In that case, he sided with the liberals to vacate the judgment of the state court that had approved an execution. He joined Justice Elena Kagan's majority opinion that the Constitution prohibits executing a person who is unable to understand why he's being punished, regardless of the particular intellectual disability he suffers, dementia or psychosis.
One more. In Murphy v. Collier, decided several weeks thereafter, the Chief Justice again sided with his liberal colleagues to halt to another execution. Over Justice Alito's dissenting opinion, which was joined by Thomas and Gorsuch, the Roberts-joined majority summarily enjoined Texas from carrying out the execution, at least until it first granted the inmate's request to be accompanied into the chamber by a Buddhist chaplain.
To be sure, Chief Justice Roberts' positions in the cases thus far discussed do not mean that he has transformed into an ideological liberal. But they do demonstrate a pattern of willingness to break with his more natural political allies on the Court and, moreover, to do so on some of the most highly charged issues of the day.
We'll look at a few more of these in the next and final post in this series.
Sunday, June 21, 2020
It's Roberts' (somewhat less right-wing) Court (Part 1)
![]() |
| Source: Reuters//Jonathan Ernst |
Indeed, most decisions of the past year--let alone of the last few decades--have been those favored by political conservatives. Whether in civil rights and liberties, the rights of the accused, employment and labor law, war and foreign affairs, and other crucial areas that define the nation's principles, the Court has largely rendered rulings that conservative Republican politicians would reach if up for a vote in their elected representative chambers.
There were some indications, even before the retirement of "swing vote" Justice Anthony Kennedy, of Roberts disrupting the holy political alliances among the Justices. ("Holy," because some members of the Court, such as the late Justice Antonin Scalia, would react to Roberts breaking with the conservatives as though it were blasphemy, heresy, or some other mortal religious transgression.) But the Chief Justice's breaking with the other conservatives has in the past few years become a foreseeable--if not expected--phenomenon of Court dynamics.
A quick survey of some major decisions in which Roberts voted on the politically liberal side of a hot-button issue should leave little doubt. Oftentimes, the Chief Justice authored the majority opinion himself--meaning that he often assigned the Court's opinion to himself in these high profile cases. And oftentimes, his vote was the deciding one in giving his liberal colleagues a victory over his usual conservative allies. Here's a sample:
Obamacare. Perhaps Roberts' best known break with the conservatives was his saving of Obamacare: his dispositive opinion for the 5-4 majority--himself and the Court's 4 liberals--upholding the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act's "individual mandate." He did so, over the bitter opposition of the other 4 Republican appointees [Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito], by characterizing the enforcement mechanism as a tax imposed within Congress's power, rather than an otherwise invalid penalty. National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius, 2012.
Three years later, Roberts again saved a major aspect of Obamacare: his 6-3 majority opinion--joined by all 4 liberals and Justice Kennedy [with Scalia, Thomas, and Alito dissenting]--upholding federal tax subsidies for all lower-income Obamacare insureds, even if their state declined to set up an insurance exchange. King v. Burwell, 2015.
Immigration. Like Obamacare, there are, of course, the immigration issues that have been among the most contentious and divisive along party lines. And like Obamacare, the Chief Justice saved DACA [the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival program] from partisan attempts at elimination. In his majority opinion, this past week, for himself and the Court's 4 liberals--once again raising the ire of the other conservative Republican Justices [Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, and Kavanaugh]--he declared the Trump administration's attempt to scrap DACA "arbitrary and capricious."
Moreover, Roberts made clear his determination that the administration's proffered reasons were dishonest, labeling them "post-hoc rationalizations" and "convenient litigation arguments." Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the University of California, 2020.
A pair of related decisions should be included here: one dealing with state immigration policy; the other dealing with immigrants and, again, the Trump administration's dishonesty.
The immigration case, eight years prior to the DACA decision, involved an Arizona law allowing the arrest of any person, without a warrant, who the police suspected was an unauthorized immigrant "removable" from the United States. The Chief Justice joined a 5-3 decision--together with 3 liberals [Justice Kagan did not participate] and Justice Kennedy, who authored the opinion--invalidating the Arizona law for interfering with federal immigration policy. The remaining Republican appointees [Scalia, Thomas, and Alito] each wrote dissenting opinions emphasizing states' rights and denying any conflict with federal law. Arizona v. U.S., 2012.
The Citizenship Question--and Dishonesty Before the Court. The other case related to the DACA decision was the one last year involving the Trump administration's attempt to insert a citizenship question on census forms. The Chief Justice's vote was decisive in thwarting this transparent attempt to undercount the population of states such as New York and California--home to large numbers of immigrants who would be discouraged from completing such a form.
In his 5-4 majority opinion, Roberts, joined by the Court's 4 liberals--and again denounced by the other Republican appointees [Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch, and Kavanaugh]--blocked this initiative of the administration, just as he did the attempted repeal of DACA, because the administration's beneficent rationale for doing so was a lie. That's my word, not his. But, his words were no less pointed.
As Roberts himself put it, there was "a significant mismatch between the decision the Secretary [of Commerce] made and the rationale he provided." For emphasis, the Chief Justice repeated that "the evidence tells a story that does not match the explanation the Secretary gave." And just in case any doubt remained, he said the same thing a third way: the "rationale—the sole stated reason—seems to have been contrived."
Roberts concluded by leaving no doubt about his contempt for the administration's dishonesty. "We are presented," he wrote, "with an explanation for agency action that is incongruent with what the record reveals about the agency’s priorities and decisionmaking process." And therefore, the Court--meaning at least the Chief Justice with the 4 liberals--"cannot ignore the disconnect between the decision made and the explanation given." Department of Commerce v. New York, 2019.
Ok, let's start with those cases. Only a few, but major and very revealing.
We'll continue our look at the Chief Justice's and his Court's "somewhat less than right-wing" record next time with LGBTQ rights, search and seizure, the death penalty, and then a few other issues.
Thursday, June 11, 2020
Trump's Justices: Gorsuch to Date (Part 3)
Pandemic restrictions, transitioning to remote teaching, exams, grading, other projects, preoccupation with breaking news, etc. Now back at last.In the first post in this series, we took a look at Justice Niel Gorsuch's voting record immediately following his appointment in the final few months of the 2016-17 term. As shown in that post, Gorsuch voted for the politically conservative side of every politically charged issue in cases involving the death penalty (pro), campaign finance restrictions (con), gun rights (pro), gay rights (con), workers' rights (con), separation of church and state (con), President Trump's travel ban (pro), and similar politically divisive matters.
Yes, there were legitimate (or semi-legitimate) arguments that supported each side in these cases. A reasonable, good-faith judge might have voted either way. But Gorsuch always chose arguments that supported the politically conservative side. Never the other side. In short, connect the dots! Moreover, Gorsuch's 100% politically conservative record was more than double the 41% conservative decisional record of the Court as a whole.
Juxtaposing his record with that of the other conservatives on the Court, as well as of the Court as a whole, in that spring of 2017 looks like this (click to enlarge).
Then, in the second post in this series, we saw that Gorsuch continued to amass a very politically conservative record throughout the 2017-18 term, his first full term on the Court. As noted in that post, in cases involving highly charged matters, Gorsuch voted for the politically conservative side virtually every time: Trump's travel ban (again, pro), immigrant rights (con), abortion rights (con), gay rights (con), union representation (con), worker rights (con), voting rights (con), ending gerrymandering (con), search and seizure protections (con), and international human rights (con). Again, connect the dots.
And again, let's juxtapose Gorsuch's voting with that of the other conservatives on the Court, as well as of the Court as a whole. His record for the first full term on the Court, the 2017-18 term, looks like this (click to enlarge).
Now, let's take a look at Gorsuch's record for the last completed term, 2018-19, his second full year on the Court. Among the cases involving those "hot-button" or politically charged issues, these were his positions:
- American Legion v. Amer. Humanist Assn. (2019) [re: the 40 Foot Cross maintained by Maryland state government]--the majority approved the cross; Gorsuch's separate concurring opinion would have lowered the separation of church and state even more by disallowing concerned groups even to complain.
- Dept. of Commerce v. New York (2019) [re: the Trump administration's proposed citizenship question on the census form]--the majority, in an opinion by the Chief Justice, disallowed the question because the administration's claimed justification was a lie; Gorsuch joined the dissenters' argument that the administration did have some legitimate reasons.
- June Med. Servs. v. Gee (2019) [re: the Louisiana abortion services restriction law]--the majority summarily blocked the law from going into effect; he joined the dissenters to approve the law until it actually resulted in unduly burdening the right to choose.
- Rucho v. Common Cause (2019) [re: partisan gerrymandering]--he voted with the majority which held that the Court should do nothing about it.
- Bucklew v. Precythe (2019) [re: lethal injection]--he authored the majority opinion to approve the use of a method of execution on an inmate, despite the inmate's particular's medical condition that would make that method excruciating.
- Moore v. Texas (2019) [re: intellectual disability of a death row inmate]--in this and several similar cases, the majority (which included Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kavanaugh) halted the execution because the state applied outdated mental health standards which the Court had previously invalidated; he joined the dissent in each case to nevertheless allow the executions.
- Murphy v. Collier (2019) [re: the Buddhist chaplain case]--the majority (which again included Roberts and Kavanaugh) halted an execution until the state honored the inmate's request to be visited by a chaplain of his faith; he joined the dissent to excuse the state and allow the execution to go forward.
- Garza v. Idaho (2019) [re: ineffective counsel]--the majority (once more including Roberts and Kavanaugh) ruled that the defense counsel's failure to file an appeal violated the defendant's right to effective counsel; he joined the dissent arguing that the defendant's waiver of appeal upon his guilty plea disposed of the question.
- Flowers v. Mississippi (2019) [re: race-based juror discharges]--the majority (which this time included Roberts, Alito, and Kavanaugh who authored the opinion) condemned as unconstitutional the “relentless” use of peremptory challenges by the prosecution to strike all black jurors, throughout 6 trials and retrials; he joined the dissent which declined to condemn the pattern.
Take a look (click to enlarge):
Sunday, July 29, 2018
The Travel Ban Decision
[Disclosure: I do think that this case was close on the legal validity of "Travel Ban #3." That being said, I do not think it's at all close whether President Trump's language and behavior on this matter have been disgraceful, dangerous, and contrary to basic American constitutional principles. I would have voted with the dissenters.]
As the world knows, the Supreme Court upheld the 3rd version of President Trump's so-called "travel ban." After several courts had invalidated the first and second versions, a third one was drafted. This executive order--Proclamation No. 9645 (as later amended by Proclamation No. 9723)--suspended the entry into this country of nationals from seven foreign nations. Five of the seven mostly-Muslim countries from the original executive order remained on the list; North Korea and Venezuela were then added.
In a 5-4 decision, the Court ruled that the Proclamation was within the "extraordinary" authority given to the President under the Immigration an Nationality Act, specifically, §1182(f).
Let's get a sense of the majority opinion, authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, and the main dissent by Justice Sonia Sotomayor. The Chief Justice's opinion for the Court included the following:
A “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States” is needed.
“Islam hates us.”
The United States is “having problems with Muslims coming into the country."
”Europe has instituted plans to “ban Muslim immigration…You know my plans. All along, I’ve been proven to be right.”
The first executive order was a needed “Muslim ban."
The second executive order, regrettably, is “watered down."
”The “travel ban . . . should be far larger, tougher, and more specific [but] stupidly that would not be politically correct.”
A "total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States" is needed.
"There is great hatred towards Americans by large segments of the Muslim population."
"They believe that "violence against Americans here in the United States is justified as a part of the global jihad."
"Shariah authorizes such atrocities as murder against nonbelievers who won’t convert, beheadings and more unthinkable acts."
"It is obvious to anybody the hatred is beyond comprehension."
"Our country cannot be the victims of the horrendous attacks by people that believe only in Jihad."
"Islam hates us."
"We can’t allow people coming into this country who have this hatred of the United States . . . [a]nd of people that are not Muslim.”
“We’re having problems with the Muslims, and we’re having problems with Muslims coming into the country.”
Muslims “do not respect us at all.”
“You know my plans [to“ban Muslim immigration”]. All along, I’ve proven to be right.”
"The lawyers and the courts can call it whatever they want, but I am calling it what we need and what it is, a TRAVEL BAN!”
“Study what General Pershing . . . did to terrorists when caught [i.e., the apparently apocryphal story about General Pershing’s massacre of Muslims in the Philippines]. There was no more Radical Islamic Terror for 35 years!”
Our Presidents have frequently used that power to espouse the principles of religious freedom and tolerance on which this Nation was founded. In 1790 George Washington reassured the Hebrew Congregation of Newport, Rhode Island that “happily the Government of the United States . . . gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance [and] requires only that they who live under its protection should demean themselves as good citizens.” President Eisenhower, at the opening of the Islamic Center of Washington, similarly pledged to a Muslim audience that “America would fight with her whole strength for your right to have here your own church,” declaring that “[t]his concept is indeed a part of America.” And just days after the attacks of September 11, 2001, President George W. Bush returned to the same Islamic Center to implore his fellow Americans—Muslims and non-Muslims alike—to remember during their time of grief that “[t]he face of terror is not the true faith of Islam,” and that America is “a great country because we share the same values of respect and dignity and human worth.”
Yet it cannot be denied that the Federal Government and the Presidents who have carried its laws into effect have—from the Nation’s earliest days—performed unevenly in living up to those inspiring words.
But the issue before us is not whether to denounce [Trump's] statements.
We must consider not only the statements of a particular President [as in the current one], but also the authority of the Presidency itself.
- it does have some legitimate basis in national security interests
- religion is nowhere mentioned
- only a small fraction of the world’s Muslim population is covered
- it covers only countries that Congress and prior administrations designated as national security risks
- it is the result of a comprehensive review process by multiple Cabinet agencies
Based on the evidence in the record [i.e., Donald Trump's language and behavior outlined by both the majority and dissent], a reasonable observer would conclude that the Proclamation was motivated by anti-Muslim animus. That alone suffices to show that plaintiffs are likely to succeed on the merits of their Establishment Clause claim.
Okay, allow me one additional "final" observation. In her dissenting opinion, Justice Sotomayor compared the Court's decision to Korematsu v. United States (1944), where the Court had upheld the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II. Naturally, Chief Justice Roberts disputed that comparison in his majority opinion.
But the Chief Justice then took "the opportunity to make express what is already obvious: Korematsu was gravely wrong the day it was decided, has been overruled in the court of history, and—to be clear—“has no place in law under the Constitution.” (Quoting from the dissenting opinion in that case of [Albany Law School's favorite son] Justice Robert H. Jackson.)
Tuesday, June 26, 2018
The Supreme's Cell Location Data Decision: Right, Revealing, and a Real Milestone
Now, that decision may not seem so earthshaking. Well of course that's a search! Well of course the Constitution generally requires a warrant and probable cause for a search! Well of course the government shouldn't be allowed to examine the data that my cellphone company has about my cellphone's location in order to monitor my every movement--unless it has some good reason (i.e., probable cause) and gets a warrant!
Well, you might think so, and the Supreme Court now agrees. Yes, now, and by a mere 5-4 vote!
Chief Justice Roberts was the deciding vote in Carpenter. He joined the Court's 4 liberals (Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan) and he assigned himself the opinion for the resulting majority. His opinion was a milestone. Not only for the particular result in the case--to repeat, government must get a warrant supported by probable cause in order to track a person's movements through cellphone location data. But also because Roberts re-invigorated one of the Court's foremost privacy-protecting landmarks. And because he declined to apply the Court's privacy-limiting precedents.
As for the 4 dissenting Justices, they all authored their own opinions presenting different arguments why Roberts and his majority were wrong.
[We've discussed at length in New York Court Watcher the nonsense--and dangerous nonsense at that--of the Supreme Court's search and seizure jurisprudence that has developed over the past few decades. It has developed largely in order to avoid excluding evidence obtained from unconstitutional searches. So the Court has disingenuously ruled that many searches are not really "searches" and, therefore, that they are not subject to constitutional protections.
A police helicopter hovering over your backyard to search your property--that's not a "search." A search of your private property away from your house--that's not a "search." A search of all the contents of your garbage put out for pick-up--that's not a "search." A search by police canines sniffing your body--that's not a "search." And lots more. No, none of these are "searches" according to Supreme Court decisions
Consequently, in such "not-a-search" situations, the 4th Amendment's prohibitions against unreasonable searches and seizures just don't apply. The government need not get a warrant or have probable cause or even have some reasonable suspicion. No, nothing! No justification whatsoever is required for these searches under the Constitution because, the Court has told us, they are not really "searches."
Yes, it's hard to believe until you actually read these decisions.
(See Supreme Court: Right on GPS Surveillance--But BEWARE! (part 1); The GPS Decision--part 2: Scalia's Dangerous Nonsense & Alito's Rebuttal; The GPS Decision--The Video)]
Let's consider the search & seizure case law particularly relevant to the issue in Carpenter.
The 4th Amendment of the Constitution protects against "unreasonable searches and seizures." In furtherance of that protection, it declares that "no Warrants [to conduct searches or seizures] shall issue, but upon probable cause." In it's 1967 landmark decision in Katz v. U.S., the Supreme Court ruled that the 4th Amendment "protects people, not places." That amendment, the Court elaborated, was intended to protect the legitimate privacy interests that people have in a free society--not the limited items that happen to be specifically mentioned in that amendment.
The Court in Katz was adopting the view expressed in one of the most famous dissents in Supreme Court history, authored by one of the truly great Justices in that history--the dissent of Louis Brandeis in Olmstead v. U.S. (1928). The majority in Olmstead held that the Constitution provided no protection against government eavesdropping on the defendant's private phone conversations. No warrant needed. No probable cause needed. The reasons? Conversations are not one of the "tangible' or "material" "things" specifically mentioned in the 4th Amendment. Also, the outside telephone wires that the government tapped belonged to the telephone company, not to the defendant.
Brandeis rejected that reasoning. He argued, in these oft-repeated lines, that the Constitution "conferred, as against the Government, the right to be let alone -- the most comprehensive of rights, and the right most valued by civilized men. To protect that right, every unjustifiable intrusion by the Government upon the privacy of the individual, whatever the means employed, must be deemed a violation of the Fourth Amendment." Nearly 40 years later, in the Katz landmark, the Court overruled Olmstead and similar decisions, and it embraced Brandeis's view of protected privacy. Henceforth, all government intrusions upon legitimate expectations of privacy would have to be justified--by probable cause supporting a warrant.
But then...
In the decades that followed Katz, as "law and order" Justices were being appointed and the Court was retrenching from decisions that were protective of the rights of the accused, the Court variously and persistently diluted that landmark. So, for example, the Court adopted the so-called "third party doctrine." In short, if you allow someone else to have information about you--e.g., your bank has records of your transactions and your phone company has records of the numbers you've called or which have called you--then you have no Katz privacy rights in that information, even from a government investigation. And so the 4th Amendment provides no protection.
(I'm not saying that follows logically, but only saying that's what the Court has ruled.)
Then there's the curious reemergence of (what I will call) the "not specifically mentioned doctrine" and, relatedly, the "trespass doctrine." In these latter dilutions of Katz--actually breaks from it--the Court has insisted, for example, that while the 4th Amendment specifies "houses" for protection, it does not mention the private property beyond a house. So there is no 4th Amendment protection for the deceptively labelled "open fields"--i.e., actually any private property a homeowner has beyond the immediate area of the home itself. The Court has also insisted that the 4th Amendment is really about property rights and about preventing the government from "trespassing"--i.e., physically invading without permission--upon one of your "tangible" "things" that are mentioned in that amendment. So, only nonconsensual invasions of your person (body), house, papers (documents), or effects (personal property). No "trespass" on one of those? Then no 4th Amendment protection.
Sooooo, under the "third party doctrine," since you've "allowed" your bank and your phone company to have records about you, the government doesn't need a warrant or probable cause--or any other justification--to search your records. Also, because your private property beyond your house is not mentioned in the 4th Amendment, the same thing. And as long as the government does not "trespass" upon you or your car (which is an "effect" or personal property), apparently no warrant or probable cause is required to conduct unlimited surveillance on your comings and goings.
That's was state of 4th Amendment search and seizure jurisprudence when the Court was deciding the cellphone location data issue in Carpenter.
So how exactly did Chief Justice Roberts reach the result he did for the Court's majority? Here's an outline of the critical highlights:
- Roberts stated the issue in the case succinctly and without any ideological slant at the outset: "whether the Government conducts a search under the Fourth Amendment when it accesses historical cell phone records that provide a comprehensive chronicle of the user’s past movements." [My emphasis whenever in bold.]
- He then described the purpose of the 4th Amendment in terms of privacy and the Court's privacy-protective landmarks:
- "The 'basic purpose of this Amendment,' our cases have recognized, 'is to safeguard the privacy and security of individuals against arbitrary invasions by governmental officials.' Camara v. Municipal Court of City and County of San Francisco, 387 U. S. 523, 528 (1967)." and
"In Katz v. United States, 389 U. S. 347, 351 (1967), we established that 'the Fourth Amendment protects people, not places,' and expanded our conception of the Amendment to protect certain expectations of privacy as well." - Roberts then declined to apply the Court's 2012 decision in the GPS tracking case, U.S. v. Jones, in terms of Justice Scalia's majority opinion which had characterized the 4th Amendment in terms of trespass upon property rights. (I.e., Scalia wrote that the GPS monitoring of the driver's movements implicated the 4th Amendment because government officials had physically trespassed on his car by attaching a GPS device without his consent--not because electronically monitoring his movements without a warrant was an intrusion upon his privacy rights. In fact, Scalia disparaged Katz as a "deviat[ion]." See The GPS Decision--part 2: Scalia's Dangerous Nonsense & Alito's Rebuttal.)
- Instead, Roberts emphasized that 5 Justices in Jones had underscored the "privacy concerns" underlying the 4th Amendment--i.e., Justice Alito's concurring opinion, joined by Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kagan, arguing that Katz governed the case and denouncing Scalia's disinterment of the trespass doctrine as outmoded and long overruled; and Sotomayor's lone concurring opinion, joining Scalia but also applying Katz.
- Reaffirming the view of those 5 Justices--a majority of the Court--instead of Scalia's "trespass doctrine," Roberts noted that, "Since GPS monitoring of a vehicle tracks 'every movement' a person makes in that vehicle, the concurring Justices concluded that 'longer term GPS monitoring in investigations of most offenses impinges on expectations of privacy'.”
- Then, addressing the "third party doctrine," Roberts explained that at the time those earlier precedents about bank records and phone records had been decided in the '70's, "few could have imagined a society in which a phone goes wherever its owner goes, conveying to the wireless carrier not just dialed digits, but a detailed and comprehensive record of the person’s movements. We decline to extend Smith [bank records] and Miller [phone records] to cover these novel circumstances."
- Roberts elaborated further on the extent and implications of cellphone data on 4th Amendment privacy rights: "[A] cell phone logs a cell-site record by dint of its operation, without any affirmative act on the part of the user beyond powering up. Virtually any activity on the phone generates [location information], including incoming calls, texts, or e-mails and countless other data connections that a phone automatically makes when checking for news, weather, or social media updates. Apart from disconnecting the phone from the network, there is no way to avoid leaving behind a trail of location data. As a result, in no meaningful sense does the user voluntarily 'assume[] the risk' of turning over a comprehensive dossier of his physical movements...The Government’s acquisition of the cell-site records was a search within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment."
- Finally, lest there be any doubt that the Chief Justice intended to re-enforce the privacy rights character of the 4th Amendment and, simultaneously, to re-inter the outmoded views that had already been overruled in Katz (but were nevertheless re-embraced in Scalia's majority opinion in Jones--the GPS case), Roberts returned to Brandeis and his dissent in Olmstead: "As Justice Brandeis explained in his famous dissent, the Court is obligated—as '[s]ubtler and more far-reaching means of invading privacy have become available to the Government'—to ensure that the 'progress of science' does not erode Fourth Amendment protections. Olmstead v. United States, 277 U. S. 438, 473–474 (1928)."
- Justice Kennedy argued that the "third party doctrine" precedents should be applied, and that they "dictate that the answer is no" 4th Amendment "search" was conducted in this case.
- Justice Thomas, echoing the majority opinion in Olmstead--rather than the Brandeis dissent--argued that the question in this case was "whose property was searched," and the cellphone location data belonged to the cellphone company, not to the defendant.
- Justice Alito argued that a subpoena for the cellphone company to present records--which was involved in this case--did not implicate the same privacy concerns as would an actual search of the defendant's premises, papers, or personal property.
- Justice Gorsuch argued against Katz as being at odds with the original meaning of the 4th Amendment and unworkable. Instead, "if a house, paper, or effect is yours, you have a Fourth Amendment interest in its protection"--but not with regard to the cellphone company's records or your location and movements.









